Your base salary is the easy part. Everything else — RSUs, ISOs, NQSOs, ESPP, restricted stock, performance shares, nonqualified deferred comp, SERPs, cash-balance overlays, and concentrated company stock — is where the planning earns or destroys the most wealth. Each instrument has its own tax timing, its own SEC paperwork, and its own trap. This is the executive playbook we run for engineering VPs, oil & gas executives, biotech founders, tech operators, and pre-IPO equity holders.
Almost every executive package we see is some combination of these six. The right plan does not treat each in isolation — it sequences them across the year, the vest, the IPO, and the exit.
The W-2 line. Fully taxable at ordinary rates. Planning lever: use this to fund the 401(k) deferral, mega-backdoor Roth, HSA, and pre-tax cash flows. Everything else builds on top of this.
Restricted Stock Units, Performance Stock Units, Restricted Stock Awards. Time-based or performance-based vesting. Taxed as ordinary income at vest. The single largest comp line for most tech & biotech executives.
The right but not obligation to buy stock at a fixed exercise price. ISOs (incentive stock options) get long-term capital gain treatment if held; NQSOs are taxed as ordinary income at exercise. AMT and timing are everything.
Employee Stock Purchase Plan. Up to 15% discount on company stock via payroll, capped at $25,000 per year. Qualified vs. non-qualified treatment changes the math materially.
Nonqualified Deferred Compensation. Lets you defer salary, bonus, or PSUs above 401(k) limits. SERP = Supplemental Executive Retirement Plan. Governed by IRC §409A — failure to comply triggers immediate tax + 20% penalty.
For founder-owners and partners at PE firms, law firms, medical groups. A defined-benefit cash balance plan layered on top of a 401(k) can shelter $200K–$350K of W-2 / K-1 income annually, fully deductible.
Restricted Stock Units are not stock. They're a promise to deliver stock at vest. Until vest there's no property, no 83(b) opportunity, and nothing to tax. At vest the entire FMV becomes ordinary W-2 income — whether you sell or hold.[1]
RSU tax math at vest:
The employer withholds federal, state, FICA, and Medicare. Default federal withholding for supplemental wages is 22% — which is almost always too low for executives in the 32%+ bracket. The underwithholding gap is where surprise April 15 tax bills come from. Always check whether your employer offers a higher elective withholding rate (37% is the supplemental ceiling).
| Grant | No tax event |
| Vest | Ordinary income on FMV |
| Hold post-vest | Basis = FMV at vest |
| Sale within 1 yr | Short-term capital gain |
| Sale after 1 yr | Long-term capital gain |
Most planners advise selling RSUs at vest unless you would buy that much company stock with cash. Holding == doubling concentration.
| % of net worth in employer | > 15% = sell |
| 10b5-1 plan available? | Strong yes — use it |
| Tax burn vs. cash bonus | Equivalent |
| Pre-IPO RSU | Special: double-trigger |
| Public company RSU | Sell-at-vest baseline |
Pre-IPO RSUs at private companies typically vest only when BOTH service and a liquidity event are met — a "double-trigger." Different tax timing entirely.
Stock options are the only common comp instrument where you actively choose when the tax event occurs (the exercise). That choice changes the rate from 37% to 20%, or creates an AMT bill that has no current cash to pay it. Most executive comp damage is done here.[2]
| Grant | No tax |
| Exercise & hold | AMT preference item |
| Exercise & same-day sell | Ordinary income (disqualifying) |
| Hold 2yr grant + 1yr exercise | All gain = LTCG |
| $100K annual limit | First $100K vesting = ISO |
ISO holding period: 2 years from grant and 1 year from exercise to qualify for LTCG. Failure = disqualifying disposition = ordinary income on the bargain element.
| Grant | No tax |
| Exercise | Ordinary income on spread |
| FICA / Medicare | Yes — W-2 wages |
| Basis post-exercise | FMV at exercise |
| Hold 1+ yr after exercise | Capital gain on appreciation only |
NQSOs are simpler than ISOs and almost always more flexible. Most board / non-employee director awards are NQSOs.
The bargain element on an ISO exercise (FMV − strike price) is invisible for regular tax but becomes an Alternative Minimum Tax preference item. Exercise 10,000 ISOs at strike $10 when stock is $90, hold them: regular taxable income is $0, but AMT taxable income is $800,000. AMT runs around 26%/28%. You may owe $200K+ on shares you can't legally sell yet, and the company doesn't withhold for it.[2]
Worked example — exercise-and-hold ISO play.
AMT preliminary at 26%/28% blend, roughly $200K of AMT. Cost to exercise: $100K cash for the strike. Total out-of-pocket day 1: $300K. Hold 12 months. Sell at $130. Federal gain = ($130 − $10) × 10,000 = $1.2M, all LTCG at 23.8% = $286K. Versus an NQSO outcome at exercise day: 37% on $800K = $296K of ordinary tax + Medicare. Savings on the ISO path: roughly $100K if everything goes right.
An ESPP under IRC §423 lets you payroll-deduct up to $25,000 per year to buy company stock at up to a 15% discount, often with a "lookback" that prices the purchase from the lower of beginning-of-period or end-of-period FMV. With the lookback, the effective discount in a rising market can easily exceed 30%.[3]
ESPP tax timing for a qualified plan:
Qualifying disposition. Sale at least 2 years after the start of the offering period and 1 year after purchase. Only the discount is ordinary income; everything above is LTCG.
Disqualifying disposition. Earlier sale — entire spread is ordinary W-2.
Section 83(b) lets you accelerate the tax event on restricted property at grant instead of vest. Most useful for founders receiving early-stage restricted stock when the FMV is essentially zero — you elect, pay tax on almost nothing, and the entire post-grant appreciation becomes long-term capital gain. Miss the 30-day deadline and the election is gone forever.[4]
| Founder restricted stock at incorporation | Almost always YES |
| Early-exercise of unvested ISOs | Often YES |
| Early-exercise of unvested NQSOs | Case-by-case |
| RSUs | NEVER — no property at grant |
| Late-stage restricted stock (high FMV) | Usually NO |
| Window | 30 days from grant / exercise |
| Who to file with | IRS Service Center where you file 1040 |
| Method | Certified mail, return receipt |
| Company copy | Required |
| Forfeiture risk | No refund of tax paid if shares forfeited |
Once you max out a 401(k) ($24,500 + $8K catch-up + match), the next deferral layer for most executives is a nonqualified deferred compensation plan. It lets you defer salary, bonus, RSU proceeds, or PSUs above the qualified-plan ceiling — no dollar limit. The trade-off: the deferral is an unsecured promise from your employer, you pick a distribution schedule years in advance, and IRC §409A enforces it with immediate tax + 20% penalty for any misstep.[5]
The 409A election rules:
Distribution events allowed: separation from service, a fixed date, change in control, death, disability, unforeseeable emergency. Acceleration is almost never permitted. Pre-tax sounds attractive — it is — but the cash is the company's, the form of payment is the company's, and bankruptcy risk is real (NQDC dollars sit with general unsecured creditors).
ERISA-exempt
Plan for a "select group of management or highly compensated employees." Avoids ERISA participation and funding requirements. Most public-company NQDCs are top-hat plans.
Supplemental Exec. Retirement Plan
Employer-funded, defined-benefit-style obligation to pay an executive an additional pension. Common at insurance, energy, and old-line industrial companies. Typically vests over 5–10 years.
Above 415(c) limits
Restores benefits an executive would have received under the qualified plan but for the IRC §415 and §401(a)(17) limits ($72K total / $360K comp cap in 2026).
Optional security wrapper
Irrevocable employer trust that holds NQDC assets segregated from operating accounts — protects against corporate raid but NOT against bankruptcy. Doesn't change tax timing.
Corporate insurance hedge
Many companies hedge NQDC participant elections by buying Corporate-Owned Life Insurance with matching investment subaccounts. Removes income-statement volatility.
Synthetic equity
Cash-settled awards mirroring stock price. Common at private companies that don't want to dilute. Vesting and 409A rules apply; treated as ordinary income at payout.
Qualified Small Business Stock under IRC §1202 lets a founder or early employee exclude up to the greater of $15 million or 10× basis of capital gain on the sale of qualifying C-corp shares held five years. The One, Big, Beautiful Bill (signed July 4, 2025) materially expanded the rules for stock issued after that date: cap raised from $50M to $75M of issuing-company gross assets, individual exclusion lifted from $10M to $15M, and a tiered partial exclusion for 3- and 4-year holds.[6]
| Entity type | Domestic C-corp |
| Gross assets at issuance | ≤ $75M (post 7/4/2025) |
| Active business | 80% of assets in qualifying trade |
| Holding period | 5 yrs (full); 4 yrs (75%); 3 yrs (50%) |
| How acquired | Original issuance, not secondary |
| Exclusion limit | Greater of $15M or 10× basis |
| Health | Hospitals, medical practice |
| Law | Law firms |
| Finance | Banks, RIAs, brokerage |
| Hospitality | Hotels, restaurants |
| Real estate | Investing or holding |
Tech, manufacturing, biotech, energy operating companies, software, and most product businesses qualify.
If you are an executive officer, director, or holder of 10%+ of a public company, you are an "insider." Every sale of company stock has to satisfy both Rule 10b5-1 (insider trading) and Rule 144 (resale of restricted/control securities). The standard solution is a pre-committed 10b5-1 trading plan adopted while you have no material non-public information.[7]
Rule 10b5-1 affirmative defense requirements (post December 2022 SEC amendments):
Plans typically specify either fixed dollar amounts, fixed share quantities, formulas, or pricing-trigger rules over a 6–24 month execution window. Companies disclose adoption / termination of officer / director plans in 10-Qs and 10-Ks.[8]
Even with a 10b5-1 plan in place, every executive sale must satisfy Rule 144 because the executive is an "affiliate." Practical requirements:
If 30–80% of your net worth sits in a single public company, you have a concentrated-stock problem — even if the stock has done beautifully. There are six ways to reduce concentration tax-efficiently. Each has a real cost, and the conflicted-product risk on some of these is well documented.[9]
Contribute, get diversification, hold 7 yrs
Contribute concentrated stock into a partnership pooled with other concentrated holders. Non-taxable contribution. After a 7-year lock-up, receive a pro-rata basket of diversified securities. Carries original cost basis — tax is deferred, not eliminated. Eaton Vance, Goldman, Morgan Stanley run these.[10]
Get 75–90% cash today
Pledge a block of stock to a counterparty in exchange for an upfront 75–90% cash advance. At settlement (1–3 years later) you deliver a variable number of shares (collar formula). You retain partial upside, get downside protection, and defer tax until settlement. Complex; FINRA arbitration awards have hit firms hard for over-recommending PVFs — treat as a real-cost product, not a free lunch.[11]
Synthetic hedge + lending
Buy a put, sell a call (zero-cost collar) to box in price, then borrow against the hedged position. Cleaner than a PVF for sophisticated clients. Watch §1259 "constructive sale" rules — a collar too tight collapses into a deemed sale.
Diversify + income + deduction
Contribute appreciated stock to a CRUT. The trust sells tax-free, reinvests, and pays you an annual unitrust amount for life or 20 years. You take a partial charitable income-tax deduction immediately. At the trust's end, remainder goes to charity / donor-advised fund.
Build basis-rich offsets
Park new dollars in a direct-indexed S&P 500 portfolio (Aperio, Parametric, Vanguard Personalized Indexing). The strategy harvests losses on individual constituents to offset gains as you trim the concentrated position over years.
The cleanest route
For most clients the simplest, lowest-cost answer is a multi-year 10b5-1 sale program scheduled around vests and earnings windows. Pay the LTCG (23.8% federal + state), reinvest into a diversified portfolio. We model this against every alternative.
Salary, bonus, RSUs (vesting schedule), ISOs (grant date, strike, expiry), NQSOs, ESPP enrollment, NQDC balance, SERP entitlement, equity in private cos. Spreadsheet view of every dollar that hits before retirement.
Move RSU withholding above the 22% default. Build quarterly estimate schedule. Use Q4 bonus or vest to true-up. Eliminates the April surprise.
Annual AMT crossover analysis. Exercise to the ceiling. If the company is on a clear IPO path, model exercise-now vs. cashless-at-IPO for each tranche.
Pre-committed selling schedule covering RSU vests, ESPP purchases, and option exercises. Coordinated with company general counsel and your equity-plan broker.
Salary deferral elections by Dec. 31; performance-bonus deferral 6 months before period-end. Distribution date locked years out. Coordinate with rest of retirement income.
For owner-operators with $1M+ profit, the cash balance / 401(k) combo shelters $300K+/yr. We design the plan with a third-party administrator (Kravitz, FuturePlan).
If you hold C-corp founder stock, we coordinate the QSBS file with your tax attorney and your trust structure before the LOI is signed. Stacking trusts pre-exit is a real planning play.
Direct indexing on new dollars + targeted exchange-fund or scheduled sales on the legacy block. We do not push PVFs by default — they're rarely the best risk-adjusted answer.
Concentrated stock + RSU vests + QSBS = a real estate-tax exposure for executives. GRATs, SLATs, dynasty trusts coordinated with the estate attorney close the wealth-transfer side.
Executive comp does not live in isolation. If you're a Canadian on a TN visa with U.S. RSUs, see the Canadian Cross-Border card. If you're an oil & gas executive with a working interest, the same card has the entity stack. If you're an owner-operator, see Cash Balance & DB Plans. If you have a federal job with a TSP overlay, see Federal, Postal & Nurses.
Your most recent equity-grant statement, your 401(k) and ESPP enrollment, your NQDC balance summary, your offer letter. We'll build the multi-year tax and exercise model and identify the moves available before year-end.
Book Your Executive Comp Review