Most people meet their finances one product at a time: a fund here, a policy there. We explain it the other way, as one story in three parts. There are nine short chapters. Each one opens the page that goes deeper, and each of those pages points to the next.
The years you are putting money in. The house, the three buckets, the four tax boxes, and how the long-term money is invested.
The years you are taking money out. Why the order of the returns matters more than the average, what Social Security covers, and the gap your savings must fill.
Who does which job. A bank, an investment firm and an insurance company each do one thing well. The plan puts each one where it belongs.
Building a financial life is like building a house. Most people start with the furniture: a fund here, a policy there, a tip from a brother-in-law. One day they look around and nothing matches. We build it the other way. First the foundation: when you want to stop working and what you need each month. Then the frame: how the money is split up. Only then the furniture, which is the actual investments.
Bucket one is money you could need in the next three years: the safety net, the big bills, the surprises. Its job is to be there, not to grow. Bucket two is the money you will need in the years after that. It can be invested, but carefully. Bucket three is the money you will not touch for the longest, and it is the one allowed to ride the market. Most of the mistakes we see are money sitting in the wrong bucket.
Every account you own sits in one of four boxes. Box one is taxed along the way: bank and brokerage accounts. Box two is taxed going in, and its growth is taxed later: annuities and savings bonds. Box three is not taxed now and all of it is taxed later: the 401(k), the 403(b), the traditional IRA. Box four is the Roth: taxed going in and, once the account is five years old and you are 59½, not again. Each box has its own rules for taking money out, so the question is how much belongs in each one.
The S&P 500 is five hundred of the largest American companies. Since 1926 it has finished the year higher about three times in four, dividends included. Most funds run by professionals have trailed it over long stretches, after fees. So the index is the yardstick for long-term money. We spread that money across different kinds of companies and bonds, so less rides on any one year.
Then the frame gets tested. Five things can knock a house down in retirement: living longer than the money, inflation, the market, interest rates, and taxes. A plan has to answer all five. Part Two starts with the one that does its damage early.
Everyone trains for the climb: save, invest, let it grow. Few train for the descent, and on Everest most of the climbers who die near the top die on the way down. Money works the same way. While you are saving, a bad year hardly matters, because you keep buying at low prices. Once you are withdrawing, a bad year early can do damage that never heals, because you are selling to pay the bills.
Take two people who retire at 65 with $1 million, all in stocks, drawing $50,000 a year, rising 3%. They get the same 26 years of returns in opposite order. One is out of money at 80. The other has $3.8 million at 91.
Before any withdrawal, count the income that arrives whatever the market does: Social Security, and a pension if you have one. When you claim changes that number for life: 62 pays the least each month, 70 the most. For a couple, the higher earner’s choice also sets what the survivor lives on.
Take what you need each month and subtract that floor. What is left is the gap. A common starting point is to withdraw about 4% of savings in the first year. That means savings of about 25 times one year of the gap. Need $2,000 a month more than the floor? That is $24,000 a year, or about $600,000. It is a place to start the math, not a promise.
Now the buckets again, counted from the first withdrawal. The first three years of the gap sit in cash. The next few years sit in dividend funds or guaranteed income. Everything else stays in the growth portfolio. In a bad market the bills come out of the first two buckets, and the third is given time. You are not forced to sell stocks while they are down.
Most mistakes come from asking one of them to do another one’s job. A bank will not grow your retirement. A mutual fund will not promise you anything. An insurance company will not give you the whole market.
In 2008 the S&P 500 fell 37% in a single year, and savings rates soon fell close to zero. People wanted the market and a limit on their losses at the same time. One answer, first sold in 2010, is the registered index-linked annuity, or RILA. An insurance company agrees to absorb the first part of a loss. In exchange you commit the money for a set term, and the growth is usually capped and counted without dividends. It can still lose money past the buffer. It fits money you can leave alone for the whole term: bucket two or three, never bucket one.
Right tool, right bucket. Bucket one is cash at the bank. Bucket two is dividend funds or guaranteed income. Bucket three is the growth portfolio. A buffered annuity can sit in bucket two or three. The last question is how much of that money should have a limit on losses, and what you would give up for it.
The story is the same for everyone. The plan at work is not. Find yours: executive compensation · business owners and cash-balance plans · the 401(k) · teachers and the 403(b) · pensions · faith-based investing.
Fifteen minutes. We’ll ask where you stand, show you the house, and tell you which chapter matters most for you right now.
Book 15 minutes → Start with chapter 1 →