Two people can earn the same average return and have very different retirements. If the market falls in the first years of withdrawals, shares get sold low and never get the chance to come back. The bucket plan is built for that problem: you spend from the safe bucket and refill it from the others in good years. Set your numbers, drag your accounts into place, then test the plan against real market history.
Order matters, not average. A crash in the first years of retirement does damage a later rebound can’t undo, so the next few years of spending are kept out of the market’s way.
Bucket 1 holds the first years of withdrawals, usually 1 to 3, in cash. Bucket 2 holds the next few, usually 4 to 6, in steadier investments. Bucket 3 holds the rest and is invested for growth.
You spend from bucket 1. When stocks are at a high, bucket 3 tops the others back up. While stocks are below their old high, bucket 3 is left alone and bucket 2 does the refilling.
We fill each bucket with the right kind of money.
Bucket 1: cash.
Bucket 2: dividend funds or guaranteed income.
Bucket 3: the North Star, our growth portfolio.
Buckets 2 and 3 can also hold a RILA, a buffered annuity. See our portfolios →
Who this is for: people taking money out of savings, or a few years from it. If you are still adding money every month and retirement is decades off, nearly all of what you have is bucket 3 money, and this page is a look ahead.
Start with what you have, then what you need from it. Only the gap gets bucketed: Social Security and a pension arrive whatever the market does, so the buckets only have to cover what those checks don’t, plus the tax on what comes out.
Press Fill it for me to see where your investable assets would go, or drag each thing you own into the bucket you’d spend it from and type what it holds. Each bucket fills toward what it needs, and each account shows a short note about holding it there.
This runs your buckets year by year from the day you retire to age 89, at a yearly rate for each bucket. Each year the bills are paid from bucket 1, every bucket earns its rate, and then bucket 3 tops up bucket 2 and bucket 2 tops up bucket 1.
Every number here is yours to set. The rates are before inflation; the fee slider is taken off buckets 2 and 3 each year, and tax makes each withdrawal bigger. Money from a 401(k) or traditional IRA is taxed in full on the way out, Roth money is not taxed, and brokerage money is taxed only on its growth, so set how your money is split and the rate for each. They are assumptions, not forecasts, and no real year earns a steady rate. Social Security is assumed to rise at the same yearly rate as your spending; the pension in step 1 has its own yearly raise. Bucket sizes in steps 1 and 2 include the tax, so moving a tax slider resizes them. The retirement age only sets how many years the money has to last: it assumes you retire today with the numbers in step 1. Use the real-history test and the wait test below to see what real markets did.
Fig. 2 — What is in each bucket at the start of each year
The chart above uses steady rates. Real markets do not move that way. This runs the same buckets, the same spending, tax and fees from each January on record, one starting year at a time. Bucket 1 earns what Treasury bills earned, bucket 2 what 10-year Treasury bonds earned, and bucket 3 what the S&P 500 earned with dividends. Spending and Social Security rise with the real inflation of those years; a pension from step 1 rises only by its own yearly raise. Bucket 3 refills the other two only after a year stocks end at or above the highest level they have reached since you retired. That is the wait rule from the rules below. Treasury bonds and the S&P 500 stand in for buckets 2 and 3; they are not our portfolios or any fund, and this is not how any real account performed.
These results are hypothetical. They come from a simplified model run on past index returns, not from any real account, and they do not guarantee future results. Indexes stand in for the buckets, and an index cannot be bought directly. The results change when you change the numbers, and may vary with each use and over time.
Fig. 3 — What was left at 89, in today’s dollars, for each year you could have retired
This uses the tax and fee sliders above and ignores the three rate sliders and the inflation number in step 1, because the returns and the inflation here are the real ones. Bucket sizes are still planned with your inflation number. Bucket 1 carries no fee, tax is a flat rate for each kind of account, and trading costs are left out. The starting years overlap, so they are not separate tests: a bad decade shows up in many of them. Years after the last one shown are left out because they have not yet run all the way to 89. With guardrails on, each year is measured against the steady-rate plan from the first chart. Required minimum distributions, tax on Social Security and Medicare premiums are not counted.
A buffered annuity (RILA) runs for a set term, here six years. If the index is up at the end, you are credited a share of the gain. If it is down, the insurer absorbs the first part of the loss and the rest is yours. This shows what one six-year term would have done in the worst, the average and the best six-year period for the S&P 500 since 1984.
Money in a brokerage account is taxed differently from a 401(k). When you sell a stock you have held more than a year, only the gain is taxed, and it is taxed on its own scale: 0%, 15% or 20%, depending on your other income that year. A big enough gain pushes part of itself into the next rate. Slide the numbers to see where a sale lands.
Fig. 4 — Where your income and your gain sit on the 2026 scale
A stock that has grown a lot does not have to be sold in one year. Each year there is room for some gain at the 0% federal rate, set by your other income. Sell only up to that line each year and the federal tax on the gain can be zero. The scale above shows one year. This shows the whole position.
This uses the filing status, other income and gain share from the scale above, and holds them and the share price the same every year. A rising price means more gain and more years. Shares sold at a gain can be bought back the same day, and the new shares start with today’s price as their cost; the wash-sale rule applies to losses, not gains. The 0% rate is federal only. California and most states tax the whole gain as ordinary income. A gain taken at 0% still counts as income, so it can make more of your Social Security taxable, raise Medicare premiums two years later and reduce health-plan credits. This is education, not tax advice; check the numbers with a tax preparer before selling.
2026 federal figures: long-term gains are taxed at 0% up to $49,450 of taxable income (single) or $98,900 (married, joint), 15% up to $545,500 or $613,700, and 20% above that, plus a 3.8% surtax on investment income once income passes $200,000 or $250,000. Other income here means wages, pensions, IRA withdrawals and the taxable part of Social Security, before the standard deduction ($16,100 or $32,200 if you are under 65; it is higher at 65 and over), which this takes off for you. A gain can also make more of your Social Security taxable and, two years later, raise Medicare premiums; neither is counted here. Shares left to heirs generally get a new cost basis at death. Stock held a year or less is taxed as ordinary income and is not shown. State tax is not included; California taxes gains as ordinary income. All the 2026 numbers.
Advanced view adds more tools here: a RILA over every six-year period since 1984, the tax scale for selling appreciated stock, and how to use the 0% band a piece at a time.
Three times this century the stock market fell and took years to get back to where it had been. The test retires you at the start of each one, with the buckets as you filled them (or as sized in step 1, if you haven’t placed anything yet), and pays your spending from buckets 1 and 2 until stocks were back at their old high. The test treats buckets 1 and 2 as cash that earns nothing and loses nothing, and bucket 3 as the S&P 500. That is harsher than real life for savings and CDs, and kinder for anything that can fall in price, such as a bond fund or a dividend fund. Dividend funds move with stocks and fell in 2008, so a bucket 2 filled with them would not have held its value the way this test assumes. The withdrawals include the tax set in the Long View.
The buckets are empty. Fill them above, or load the example and press play.
What the test leaves out. A longer runway is not free. Every year of spending held in buckets 1 and 2 is money that is not in stocks, and over a long rising market that can leave you with less than staying invested would have. Size the first two buckets for the wait you want to be able to sit through, not as large as they will go.
S&P 500 calendar-year total returns, dividends included, rounded to one decimal, before fees. Withdrawals include the tax set in the Long View. In this test “old high” means where stocks stood on the day you retired, which stays the highest level of your retirement until the wait ends. Spending rises by the raise you set, which is your assumption and may differ from what prices did in those years. “With no buckets” counts every withdrawal made while stocks were below that level.
The grocery money, the property tax, the trip: all of it comes out of the cash bucket. Bucket 2 keeps it topped up, and pays a bill itself only if bucket 1 runs dry. What the market did this month stops deciding what you can spend this month.
After a year stocks finish at or above the highest level they have reached since you retired, bucket 3 sells enough to bring buckets 1 and 2 back to their full years. You are selling stocks when they are up, on purpose, instead of whenever a bill happens to come due.
Bucket 2 refills bucket 1 and the stocks are given time. How much time is what sizes the first two buckets: after 2000 it took seven years of spending before stocks were back, and after 2008 it took five.
| Bucket | Its job | What usually goes in it | What to watch |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 · Now | Pay the bills for the first years | Savings, money market funds, and CDs or Treasury bills that come due in time | It has to be reachable without a penalty |
| 2 · Soon | Refill bucket 1; hold the middle years | High-quality bonds, bond or CD ladders, dividend funds, guaranteed income, fixed or buffered annuities (RILAs) with a set term | Surrender periods; bond prices fall when rates rise; dividend funds still move with stocks |
| 3 · Later | Grow for the years further out | Diversified stock funds, inside a 401(k), an IRA, a Roth or a brokerage account; a buffered annuity (RILA) for a share of it | Big swings from year to year; it needs time |
What it costs. The first two buckets are not invested for growth, so the more years they hold, the less of your money rides the market in the good stretches. After a long rally, a plan that stayed fully invested can end with more. The buckets earn their keep in the years you would otherwise be selling low.
A bucket is about when, not about tax. A 401(k), a Roth IRA and a brokerage account can sit in the same bucket and be taxed three different ways. Which account each dollar comes out of is the other half of the plan, and it has its own page: tax-efficient withdrawal.
The bucket plan changes what a bad market forces you to do. With the next several years of spending already set aside, a crash becomes something you wait out instead of something you sell into. That protection has a price, because the first two buckets are not growing with the market. So the sizes are worth getting right, the buckets have to exist before the first withdrawal, and they have to be refilled by rule instead of by mood.
The buckets work alongside their neighbors: sequence of returns · the 4% rule · Social Security timing · the North Star, our core portfolio · the full Planning Center.
Fifteen minutes. We’ll map the income you can count on, size the three buckets against what’s left, and show you which of your accounts is doing which job today.
Book a retirement-income review → Read: sequence of returns →