At The Movies: A Sober Take On The Summer's Big Alien-Encounter Spectacle
WSJ's Kyle Smith reviews the Russo brothers' new sci-fi tentpole. A weekend watch — and a small lesson about spectacle versus substance.
The Review
In this week's Off Duty, critic Kyle Smith trains a sober eye on the summer's big alien-encounter spectacle from the Russo brothers — the directors behind some of the biggest box-office tentpoles of the era. The verdict, in short: dazzling to look at, thin underneath. Enormous effects budget, familiar beats, not much that stays with you on the drive home.
It's a fun watch for a Friday night — just don't expect it to linger.
Forgive the occupational hazard, but a blockbuster that's all effects and no story reminds me of a certain kind of stock: all narrative, no earnings. Thrilling on the screen, dangerous in the portfolio at any price. The films that endure — and the companies that compound — tend to be the ones with an actual story underneath the spectacle.
Themes In This Article
- FilmThe Russos' sci-fi tentpole
- CultureSpectacle vs. substance
- TakeawayStory beats effects
Q2 Review — 15 Minutes, Phone Or Zoom
Bring your statement; we translate the headline into a position-level decision.
Book Q2 Review →View Portfolios →