Phil Scott is 71 and a former Navy pilot. He has run stock portfolios since 1986. Last month he and his partner, Jim Atwood, walked out of JPMorgan Chase (JPM). The bank wanted them to spread their clients' money around. They didn't want to.
The Journal's Miriam Gottfried tells the story. Some of their longtime clients had nearly 20% of their holdings in a single stock. The names include Nvidia (NVDA), Broadcom (AVGO) and Dell Technologies (DELL). In March the bank gave Scott until January 2027 to diversify, he says. Instead the two men started their own firm, Latigo Peak Partners. It looks after $18.6 billion.
Give them their due. They were right for years. Nvidia climbed 510% over the past five years, against about 57% for the S&P 500. One client put in $250 million in 2020 and has taken out $167 million since. That portfolio was worth $927 million on April 30. More than 16% of it was Nvidia, and nearly 10% was Broadcom. The portfolios did well partly because "we let our winners run," Atwood told the Journal. Selling would also have meant big tax bills on those gains.
Then the test came
On Thursday, Nov. 5, Nvidia fell 9.3%, Broadcom fell 10% and Dell fell 15%. A Morgan Stanley educator told the Journal that one big position is usually four times as jumpy as a spread-out benchmark. Nvidia has also trailed the S&P 500 by 15 points over the past 12 months. Scott's answer is discipline about when to sell. His firm uses price rules, and Thursday tripped them on four stocks. None of the four was Nvidia, Broadcom or Dell.
Our read
This is Investments/Risk · IN04, and the word is concentration. We'll be plain about our own books. Nvidia is held at weight in 31 of our model books, at a little over 5% on average. Broadcom is in 29. Nothing added. So we own these companies too. The difference is size. When one stock is 16% of everything, a 9.3% drop in it takes about a point and a half off the whole portfolio in a day. A family with $927 million can shrug that off. A family that lives on its savings can't always do that.
Here's the connection to your own money. Find the biggest single stock on your statements. Company stock from work counts. Work out what share of your savings it is. If it's large, take three questions to your adviser this week. Ask what you paid for it and what tax a sale would bring. Ask whether you can trim it over a few years. Ask what the rule for selling is. It's easier to pick a size on a calm day than on a day like Thursday. If you'd like help running those numbers, that's what a review is for.
