Dana Auslander owns seven Hermès handbags. She also runs a fund that owns dozens more. Hermès won't sell her bags to flip, so she buys them from resellers. Her first fund just closed, and the number is worth a look.
The Journal's Kate King has the details. The fund is from Luxus, a New York asset manager Auslander started in 2021 after years at Blackstone and other firms. It raised $1 million and bought 56 Birkin and Kelly bags. Over 15 months it netted nearly 24%. Hermès stock fell more than 33% over the same stretch.
How a handbag makes money
The trick is scarcity. Hermès makes the bags in French workshops and sells them only in its own shops. Getting one can take years of shopping there. So people pay extra on the resale market. Luxus buys from wholesalers in Japan, usually at 5% to 10% above the store price. Then it resells through auction houses and online platforms. It sold 52 of the 56 bags. When new sales slow, Auslander told the Journal, "resale does really, really well."
Now the catches, and the Journal lists several. The minimum is $100,000, and only accredited investors can get in. That means people who pass an income or wealth test, such as $200,000 a year in income. The first fund had seven of them. Tastes can turn fast. Prices for famous watches soared during the lockdowns and then dropped hard. A rival platform for collectibles reported more than $1 million in losses in the first half of the year. The bags need secure, climate-controlled storage. Fakes are a risk, so every bag gets checked more than once. We'd add one of our own. A handbag pays no dividend while you wait.
Our read
This is Investments/Risk · IN04, with a dose of Behavioral. We like the story, and we'd keep the number in its place. One fund, 15 months and seven investors is a good start. It isn't a track record yet. A Bernstein analyst gave the Journal the plain comparison. Hermès shares have returned 16% a year over the past 35 years, he said. He also called the shares a bit easier to sell. A bag has to find a buyer first. Hermès is not held in our model books.
Here's the connection to your own money. Anything sold as an "alternative" should pass one test first. You should be able to live without that money for years if no buyer shows up. Look at your own accounts this week and add up what you can't sell quickly. That includes private funds, collectibles and a share of a business. If the total covers money you'll need soon, that's the thing to fix. A closet is a fine place for a handbag and a poor place for the rent money. If you'd like help sorting what's liquid from what isn't, that's what a review is for.
