If you bought a house in Los Angeles in 1985, you did very well. Few places in America did better. Among the 30 big metro areas in one study, only Seattle and San Diego beat you. And a plain S&P 500 index fund still beat all three. That's the finding of a study in Monday's Journal.
Derek Horstmeyer is a finance professor at George Mason University. He asked a question many families face. Say you have extra money. You can buy a bigger house, or you can buy a smaller one and invest the rest. He ran the numbers back to 1985 for most states and the top 30 metro areas.
Los Angeles homes returned 5.98% a year after taxes and mortgage interest. Seattle returned 6.22% and San Diego 6.05%. The S&P 500 returned 7.57%. The gap looks small. Over 40 years it isn't. Here's our own math, if each rate held every year. A dollar growing at 7.57% ends up at about 18.5 times its start. At 5.98% it's about 10 times. In the weakest state, Illinois, homes returned 2.36% a year.
What the study counts, and what it leaves out
The study is fair in a few ways. Its buyer puts 20% down and borrows the rest, so the home gets the lift of a mortgage. It subtracts the interest. It taxes both sides, and it sells both at the end of 2025. It also shows that stocks were bumpier. They swung 16.5% a year, against 9% for the average home.
It leaves some things out, too. You can live in a house. You can't live in an index fund, and the study doesn't count the rent you save. A mortgage also forces you to save every month. Most of us don't invest the difference that faithfully. The professor grants part of this. A home's value, he writes, goes beyond its price. His point is narrower. Home prices in even the hottest areas “couldn't match the stock market over the long run.”
Our read
This is a Housing story (M6) with an Investments lesson (IN04). We don't read it as a case against owning a home. We read it as a case against stretching for the biggest one. Buy the house your family needs. Past that point, the study says extra dollars have grown faster in stocks. The study looks back 40 years. It doesn't promise the next 40.
Here's where it touches your own money. Add up what you own and see how much of it is your house. For many Los Angeles families, it's most of it. This week, write down two numbers. One is your home's rough value minus the mortgage. The other is everything you hold in retirement and investment accounts. If the house is far bigger, your wealth rides on one street. A review can show what it would take to even that out over time. You'd check the foundation before adding a second story.
