Josh Chin is a Wall Street Journal reporter. He opened a 163-page file at the National Archives about his great-grandfather. The first half told one life story. The second half showed that much of it was invented. That included the family name Chin still carries.
Chin tells the story in the weekend Review section. The file said Chin Him was born in 1885 in San Francisco's Chinatown. His real name was Lee Him, and he was born in southern China. He used the false name for almost 40 years so officials would treat him as a U.S. citizen.
The history explains why. U.S. law shut out nearly all Chinese immigrants from 1882 to 1943. About 300,000 Chinese people came anyway, Chin writes. Most of them, historians think, were boys and men who claimed a citizen as their father. They were called “paper sons.” Two events opened the door. An 1898 Supreme Court ruling confirmed that people born here are citizens, whatever their race. Then the 1906 San Francisco earthquake set off fires that burned the city's birth records. A man could bring witnesses to say he was born there. No record could prove he wasn't.
What a new name cost
Lee Him sold slots. He told officials about sons who weren't his. One, Chin writes, was “a fictional child.” Accounts from the time put the price at around $100 for each year of a buyer's age. Chin figures one slot cost something like $30,000 in today's dollars. Buyers also had to get through questioning by officials. One paper son carried a study sheet with 120 questions and answers. One question asked how many chicken coops his house had. The answer was one.
The secret reached the next generation. Investigators questioned Chin's grandfather in 1960. He confessed and asked not to be sent to China. He lost his citizenship at once. He got it back in 1974, under his real name. He never told his children. Chin's father and aunt found his naturalization papers after he died in 2014.
Our read
We take no side on the old law. For us this is an Estate story, and the lesson is about paper. A family's legal life sits in documents. Names, birth dates and citizenship papers help decide who can claim a pension, a survivor benefit or an inheritance. When a name on one paper doesn't match another, the family has to prove the link. That can take months. By then the one person who knew the story may be gone.
Here's the tie to your own plan. Check the names on your beneficiary forms against the names on your IDs. A maiden name, a nickname or a changed spelling can slow a claim. This week, put birth certificates, marriage records, citizenship papers and military discharge papers in one folder. Then tell one person where it is. Chin's father and aunt found the papers after the death. Your family should find them sooner. A review is a good time to go through that folder together, while the people who know the story can still tell it.
