Election night was Tuesday, Nov. 3. One research analyst in Manhattan spent three hours of it on the phone with worried clients. Between calls he got down on the floor and did push-ups to stay awake. The week only got stranger from there.
The Journal's weekend lead tells the week in three moves. On Wednesday the Dow had its best day since April. On Thursday the selling hit, and $2.5 trillion came off the Nasdaq Composite. On Friday tech stocks got some of it back. For the week the Dow lost 0.9%, the S&P 500 lost 2.7% and the Nasdaq lost 3.4%.
Who sold on Thursday
Part of Thursday's selling was done by rule. Some funds are built to cut stocks when the VIX, Wall Street's fear gauge, jumps. Barclays estimates those funds cut their stock exposure by 30 percentage points in one day. That's the biggest one-day cut since February 2020. Options trading set a record too, in data going back to the 1970s. One San Francisco investor saw a six-figure sum leave his retirement account by midmorning. "You just watch," he told the Journal.
In Monday's paper, the Journal's James Mackintosh added up the damage. Micron (MU) fell 23% in two days. CoreWeave (CRWV) fell 19%. Nvidia (NVDA) and Broadcom (AVGO) each fell 12%. He counts Thursday as the S&P 500's 15th-worst day since 2009. The fear is that new governors in states like Texas and Ohio promised to pause data-center building. His own view is that the new politics is "probably not as severe as the consensus trade suggests." On trading politics, he wrote, "no one knows anything." Other pros split. One fund manager told the Journal slower growth for AI stocks looks hard to avoid. A bank's investment chief said his team has started to think about looking for things to buy. Those are claims, and they don't agree.
Then came Monday, Nov. 9, which is in neither paper. By our own pull, the S&P 500 rose 2.35% to 7,549.94. The Dow rose 2.15% to 52,389.75, and the Nasdaq rose 2.74%. The VIX fell to 19.92, from 28.18 on Thursday. News reports tied the jump to oil falling on hopes for peace between the U.S. and Iran. Nvidia still fell about 4% on news of its own, by our own pull. The S&P 500 now sits 3.44% under its Oct. 6 record of 7,818.93.
Our read
This is a Behavioral story, and an Investments/Risk · IN04 one. The funds that sold Thursday didn't stop to think. A formula said sell, so they sold. Two trading days later, the index had most of the week's loss back. We aren't forecasting what comes next. We're pointing at the difference between a formula and a plan. For the record, Nvidia is held at weight in 31 of our model books, TSMC in 30, Broadcom in 29 and Micron in 23. CoreWeave is in one book, at 10% of its chips sleeve. Nothing added.
Here's the connection to your own money. Your 401(k) or IRA has a rebalancing rule, or it should. It says how much goes in stocks and when you move it back to that mix. Look for it this week, while things are calmer. If you can't find one, write it down in two lines. A rule you wrote on a quiet day won't sell for you on a loud one. You choose the umbrella when the sky is dry. If you'd like a second set of eyes on your rule, that's what a review is for.
