Jason Zweig keeps a pile of gloomy emails. Some came in November 2024, from readers sure the election would wreck the markets. Others came four years earlier, from readers on the other side who were just as sure. Several swore they'd move everything to cash. This week he wrote back to ask if they had. Nobody answered.
Zweig writes The Intelligent Investor column for the Journal. His point this weekend is that investors jump to conclusions after a vote. He borrows an idea from the psychologist Daniel Kahneman, who called the mind a machine built to jump to conclusions. Big news feels permanent on the day it lands.
Look at the days after this vote. On Wednesday, Nov. 4, home-builder stocks rose 7%. Lockheed Martin (LMT) fell 7% the same day. Then chip makers Advanced Micro Devices (AMD) and Micron (MU) each lost more than one-sixth of their market value in a few hours. Zweig doubts those businesses changed that much that fast. Common sense, he writes, says "calm down."
He tested a favorite saying
The saying is that split government is good for stocks. Zweig counts 130 years since the Dow began in 1896. Power was split in only 35 of them. In those years the Dow gained 6.6% a year on average, by Dow Jones Market Data. The S&P 500 gained 7.4%. Both trail the long-run average for stocks. Neither figure counts dividends, and he says adding them wouldn't change the result. He also sorted the years by which party held which branch, and one mix looked better than the other. He doesn't trust that either, because two rough years, 1974 and 2008, pull one side down. His own verdict is that the numbers don't "mean anything." Thirty-five years is too few to predict with.
He offers one more pair of numbers. The S&P 500 grew 13.4% a year under the last president. So far under this one, it's 13.4% too. Both figures count dividends.
Our read
This is a Behavioral story, and we think Zweig has it right. We don't have a view on which party is better for stocks, and his numbers say nobody should. What he offers in place of a forecast is a short list of rules. Write down what your money is for. Set the mix you'll rebalance back to. Use a checklist before you buy or sell. Keep any hunch trading in a small, separate account. For the record, Lockheed Martin is held at weight in 29 of our model books and Micron in 23. Nothing added.
Here's the connection to your own money. The first item on his list has a formal name, an investment policy statement. It's one page that says what the money is for and how it's split. Check this week whether you have one. If you work with an adviser, ask to see yours. If there isn't one, write three lines tonight. Say what the money is for, what the mix is, and when you rebalance. It's a seat belt, and you buckle it before the car moves. If you'd like help writing yours, that's what a review is for.
