In 2019 a homeowner near Minneapolis took the cheaper loan. It was an adjustable-rate mortgage. Its starting rate sat about 1.25 percentage points under the 4% fixed rate of the day. He planned to move within seven years. He didn't. In January his rate can go as high as 7.75%, up from 2.75%.
His minimum payment goes from $6,800 a month to $9,300. Nicholas G. Miller told his story in the Wall Street Journal of Wednesday, Nov. 11. The owner still owes about $600,000. "I should have taken the fixed mortgage," he told the paper.
He has company. An adjustable-rate mortgage, or ARM, gives you a low rate for a set stretch, usually three to 10 years. After that the rate floats with the market. Intercontinental Exchange, a data firm, counts 186,000 of these loans that reset next year. The typical payment rises $645 a month at first. It reaches $754 once the loan's caps let the full increase through. The biggest group took seven-year loans in 2020. Their typical bill goes up 43%, or $1,269 a month.
Why people still sign up
Fixed mortgage rates are well above 7%, the paper said. Freddie Mac's weekly survey put the 30-year loan at 7.18%. So a lower starting rate looks good again. ARMs were 11.4% of mortgage applications in the week ended Oct. 30. They were 6.3% at the start of the year. The loans are safer than they were in 2008. They're about 5% of active mortgages now, and lending rules are tighter. Among borrowers whose payments rose in 2024 and 2025, more than 98% of those who were current stayed current six months later.
One owner in the story got ahead of his reset. His payment was headed from around $4,000 to almost $6,500. He paid an extra $100,000 toward the loan. That brought the payment down to around $5,000.
Our read
This one is Housing (M6) and Cash Flow (M5). An ARM is a bet that you'll move or refinance before the low rate ends. Life doesn't always keep that date. The Minneapolis owner is leaning toward another seven-year ARM at 5.75%, the paper said. That may be a fair choice for him. It's also the same bet again. And the timing matters. After October's hot inflation report, the Journal said investors no longer doubt a Fed rate increase on Dec. 9. An ARM's rate follows an index tied to short-term rates, so a Fed move can show up in the next reset.
If you have an adjustable loan, pull out the mortgage note this week and find three things. First, the date of your first reset. Second, the cap, which is the most the rate can rise at one time. Third, the margin, which is what the lender adds on top of the index. Then ask your loan servicer what the payment would be at today's rates, and put that number in your budget now. These are general planning principles, not advice. It's easier to measure a wave from the shore than from the water. If you'd like a second set of eyes on the loan papers, bring them to a review.
