The count is in. California voters said no to Proposition 40. It would have put a one-time 5% tax on the net assets of residents worth more than $1 billion. The AP called it Monday, Nov. 9, with the measure behind by about 5.5 percentage points. The Journal's Paul Kiernan and Laura J. Nelson reported the result on Tuesday, Nov. 10.
A healthcare workers union wrote the measure. The union estimated it would raise $100 billion over five years. That money was meant to offset Medicaid cuts signed into law last year. Nothing like it had been tried in modern America. Most of our taxes fall on what people earn. This one would've fallen on what people own.
The other side spent big. Google co-founder Sergey Brin was among them, along with other tech executives and billionaires. They put hundreds of millions of dollars into the fight. For every dollar the measure's supporters raised, the opponents raised more than ten. The antitax campaign said it wants to work with the incoming governor on “more thoughtful” solutions. The paper says the result leaves him with a major budget problem to solve.
Two more measures, one still uncalled
Some of that money went to two companion measures. One would have set new rules on state spending and required audits. It failed, according to the AP. The other would ban wealth taxes in California. The yes side was narrowly ahead, and the AP hadn't called it when the paper went to print. The union's president says they'll try again in 2028 unless lawmakers fix the healthcare cuts first.
Our read
This is a Tax and Estate story, and most of our readers live in California. So let's be plain about what changed. Nothing. No tax rule is different this week from last week. If the ban passes, a future wealth tax would be harder to put in place. We'll watch that count. For the very wealthy, where you live and where you're taxed stays a live question. Every state writes its own rules. For everyone else, the lesson is simpler. A ballot measure is a proposal until it passes. Some people may have made real decisions this fall on the chance that it would.
Here's the connection to your own plan. If you delayed a sale, moved a trust, or thought hard about leaving the state this fall because of Prop. 40, pull that decision back out this week. Look at it with the result in hand. For everyone else, the check is simpler. Your year-end moves, a stock sale, a gift to the kids, a trust update, all rest on the law as it stands. None of it changed on election night. A choice made under a headline deserves a second look in calm weather. A review is a good place to do it.
