In the spring they said yes. About 40 students told Whittier College, near Los Angeles, that they'd be there in the fall. Then August came, and they weren't. The school has about 910 students, so that's a real hole. Colleges have a name for it. They call it melt. The Journal's Roshan Fernandez told the story on Wednesday, Nov. 11.
Whittier's melt rate hit 17% this year. It was in the high single digits before the pandemic and 12% last year. Some schools now watch 20% of their deposits disappear. The reason starts with how families commit. A deposit is usually a few hundred dollars, and you don't get it back. It's credited toward tuition if you show up. And more students now put money down at two schools, or even three.
The average student placed 1.4 deposits for the class that started in 2025, up from one in 2019, according to the consultant EAB. Higher-income families do it more. Those earning over $120,000 averaged 1.5 deposits. A second deposit keeps a second school on the hook, and some families use that to bargain for more aid all summer. One academic adviser told the paper that May 1 decision day is now “like halftime.”
When the first bill comes
Whittier makes every student who deposits meet with a financial-aid counselor. One admissions officer said that's the moment it gets real, because “now the first bill is due.” The school also has faculty reach out over the summer and offers free tuition to students who qualify. Georgia State took a different route. It made registration simpler and cut its melt from 22% in 2024 to 7% this year. Even there, about a fifth of the students who melt don't go on to college anywhere else right away. The head of a national group of admissions counselors calls them drifters.
Our read
This is a Cash Flow story, module M5, dressed up as an education story. The paper reports that families use a second deposit to keep bargaining. We're not telling anyone to do that. We're pointing at the thing underneath it. The first bill is when the plan meets reality. Some families find out in August what the year really costs. A few hundred dollars in deposits is small money. The gap between a glossy brochure and a tuition bill isn't.
Now bring it to your own plan. If there's a high-school senior in your house, the item is the college fund and the monthly line that feeds it. This week, pull up each school's net price calculator. That's the tool on the school's website that estimates your cost after aid. Write the full first-year bill next to what the 529, the college savings account, and your monthly cash flow can cover. Do it before any deposit goes in. A family that knows its number in March is a lot less likely to melt in August. It's easier to check the forecast before you pack the car. A review is a good place to run those numbers together.
