The usual career tip is to keep moving. Take the better offer, then the next one. Now a Wharton professor who has studied careers for more than 20 years says the evidence points the other way.
Matthew Bidwell made the case in the Wall Street Journal of Wednesday, Nov. 11. He calls it the "insider advantage." In his words, "staying put can often be the fastest path to success."
Start with promotions. In a 2015 study, he asked M.B.A. graduates how many people they managed in each job. On average, those who changed companies ended up managing no more people than before. Those who changed jobs inside one company nearly doubled the count. A 2019 study followed nearly 60,000 workers in Finland and found the same pattern. People were almost six times as likely to win a real promotion inside their firm as by leaving it. And a 2021 study found that 74% of top executives came up from within.
A new job takes time
A new boss knows little about you, he writes. So the bigger job rarely goes to the stranger. New hires can take two to three years to hit their stride. Then there's pay. A move often brings a raise. But he also looked at a long-running national survey of young workers. People who changed employers more often after their mid-twenties earned less by their mid-thirties than people who moved less.
He's careful about the limits. Leaving makes sense if you dislike the work, feel underpaid, or see no room to grow. He just wants you to pick the next employer for the long run.
Our read
This is Career, and it touches Cash Flow (M5). A job offer comes with one loud number, the salary. The quiet numbers often matter more. Real hourly pay was flat in October after inflation, the Journal's editorial page noted. So a raise that only matches prices isn't much of a raise. And years at one employer build things an offer letter doesn't show. Many 401(k) matches become yours only after a few years. A pension counts years of service. Leave early and some of that money stays behind. That part is our point. The professor didn't make it.
Here's the check, whether or not you're looking. Open your benefits portal this week and find your vesting date. That's the day the employer's match is fully yours. If you have a pension, find your years of service credit too. Write both numbers next to any offer before you compare. These are general planning principles, not advice. Count the whole paycheck before you change the name printed on it. If an offer is on your desk, a review can set the two packages side by side.
