A reader in Pennsylvania grew up in Philadelphia's Logan neighborhood. Two blocks from home, the seafood store kept live carp in an open tank on a table. Sawdust covered the butcher's floor. The deli had pickle barrels. He still sees all of it clearly. He's 98.
The Journal asked readers which small businesses they remember fondly and what they miss most. Demetria Gallegos gathered the answers in the Tuesday, Nov. 10 paper. She began with her own memory. Two corner groceries stood near her childhood home. She'd find quarters under the sofa and go buy candy by herself. Going alone was half the fun, she writes.
The letters share a theme, and it isn't price. One man's father sold hardware in Decatur, Ill., for more than 35 years, starting in 1944. The clerks there could lecture on every kind of screw. Walk in at one minute to closing and the clerks still gave you their full time. That could mean half an hour. A woman who grew up in Summit, N.J., bought her first record from the man whose name was on the shop. That shop lasted until 2025. Her pharmacist knew every family's names and medicines. When a shop like that closed, she writes, it felt like losing a family member.
The doctor who came to the house
A reader in Arlington, Va., mourns Ayers Hardware. It said in July that it would close after almost 80 years. What he misses most is that the place didn't feel “optimized.” Newer stores, he says, move people in and out fast. A shopper can make 10 trips and never speak to anyone. A New York reader misses the milkman with his glass jugs and the knife sharpener who came to the door. Most of all, that reader misses the family doctor. He made house calls and knew the family's history without a chart. A California reader recalls drive-through dairies in Fontana that gave kids free Popsicles.
Our read
We put this one under Behavioral, with a Retirement note. Hardly anyone in these letters missed a low price. They missed being known. The hardware clerk, the pharmacist and the doctor each carried part of a family's story in their heads. That service was free, and it's mostly gone. Money can't buy it back. It can still be spent on purpose. A few dollars more at a local shop you love helps keep its doors open.
Here is where it meets your own plan. The pharmacist who knew your medicines has been replaced by a login. So the list has to live with you. This week, write one page with your doctors, your medicines, your accounts and the people to call. Give a copy to the person who'd step in if you couldn't. A review is a good place to find what the page leaves out. Write it while the memory is as clear as that carp.
