Families paid premiums to a life insurer. Some of that money ended up in loans backed by European soccer clubs and a Canadian budget airline. The firm behind those deals is now in bankruptcy. Its co-founder has pleaded guilty to fraud. And a state regulator wants a court to take the insurer over.
Alicia McElhaney reported the story in the Wall Street Journal of Thursday, Nov. 12. The insurer is Atlantic Coast Life Insurance. Its owner is Advantage Capital Holdings, a private asset manager that goes by A-CAP. A-CAP's insurers put policyholder money into 777 Partners, a Miami investment firm that has since failed. Atlantic Coast Life reported nearly $1.4 billion in invested assets at the end of last year. Nearly one-third sat in investments once tied to 777, according to filings the Journal reviewed.
The South Carolina regulator's petition tells how it grew. In 2020, A-CAP's insurers lent 777 $46 million. The loan was amended more than 100 times. The balance grew to more than $700 million, the petition says. The regulator alleges the insurer misreported its exposure. He alleges the assets now look to be worth "substantially less than forecast."
What the regulators did
South Carolina asked a court in September to strip A-CAP of control and put the insurer into rehabilitation. The Journal likened that to a state takeover. In October, Florida and Virginia moved to stop it from selling new policies. The ratings firm AM Best downgraded Atlantic Coast Life and a sister insurer in September. It said their portfolios hold assets "not traditionally associated with insurance company investments."
A-CAP disputes much of this. It says it was defrauded by 777's co-founder. It says it took control of the collateral to protect policyholders. It disagrees with the downgrade and has challenged Florida's order. It has said it's weighing all its options against the South Carolina regulator. No court has ruled on the takeover request, as far as the paper reports.
Our read
This is Insurance and Consumer Protection (M11). We can't say how this case ends, and we make no claim about any reader's coverage. The lesson is older than this insurer. A fixed rate from an insurer is a promise, and a promise is only as strong as the company behind it. Insurers have put more money into private deals in recent years, the Journal noted, and regulators are watching. A rate that beats everyone else's has to come from somewhere. Often it comes from riskier or harder-to-sell investments. The trap to avoid is buying on the rate alone.
So here is the check for this week. Pull out any life policy or annuity you own. Find the name of the company that issued it, which may differ from the name on the brochure. Look up its AM Best rating, and see if the rating changed this year. Then look up your state guaranty association and read its limit for your kind of policy. Know that limit before you put more than that with one insurer. These are general planning principles, not advice. You check the bridge before you drive the family across it. Bring the policy to a review and we'll read it with you.
