Two grandparents wanted to watch their granddaughter dance in "The Nutcracker." They searched online and saw seats at about $150 each. The theater's own box office had them for $25. The couple never checked it. They felt embarrassed, gave their daughter an excuse and stayed home.
That happened two winters ago at the Egyptian Theatre in DeKalb, Ill. The theater's director told the story to the Journal's Hanna Krueger. Her report ran Thursday, Nov. 12. It shows resale markups reaching the smallest stages. Think open-mic nights and a high school singing contest.
Take a poetry slam at the Rebel Lounge in Phoenix. A ticket costs about $12 at the door. On StubHub the same ticket was listed at $24. The Journal bought one. Four minutes later, the club's owner said, someone paid $12 for that ticket at the club's own box office. Then it was sent on to the Journal. He called it a speculative ticket, one the seller didn't own when it was listed.
Selling a ticket you don't have
The trade calls this speculative selling. A broker lists a ticket it doesn't own yet. A fan pays the markup. Only then does the broker go to the venue and buy the seat. Brokers told the Journal that software copies club calendars to make the listings. Search engines often show resale sites ahead of the box office. StubHub and Vivid Seats told investors they rely heavily on search engines for traffic.
Two clubs have sued StubHub for false advertising. One suit says a $22 punk show was listed at $165. StubHub says the suits are without merit and that it bars speculative sales. Vivid Seats says it prohibits undisclosed speculative ticketing. SeatGeek says it doesn't want such tickets on its site. Arizona outlawed the practice in 2024. California passed its own ban in September.
Our read
This is Insurance/Consumer Protection · M11, with a Cash Flow · M5 twist. The trap here is small and quiet. Nobody robbed those grandparents. They just believed the first price they saw. A resale price is a broker's guess at what you'll pay. The face price is still sitting at the venue. On a $12 ticket the extra is lunch money. On a family row of $150 seats, it's a real line in a December budget.
Now your own holiday spending. Say your budget has a line for shows this season, a recital, a concert, a Nutcracker. Make one check this week. Before you pay, find the venue's own website or call its box office. Compare that price with the one on your screen. Tell the grandparents in your family to do the same, since they may not know to look. The cheap seat is easiest to find before the night of the show. We're glad to walk through the rest of the holiday budget with you in a review.
