Roland Fryer thought he knew what he'd find. The Harvard economist expected to show that members of Congress trade on inside knowledge. He and his team checked more than 30,000 stock purchases that lawmakers reported. While that work went on, he bought two funds that copy those trades.
He wrote up the result in The Wall Street Journal's opinion pages this weekend. He found "far less evidence of widespread insider trading than I expected." Over three months and over a year, the typical purchase did about as well as the market. When he gave bigger purchases more weight, they came out ahead by an estimated 3.8 percentage points over a year. He calls that estimate too uncertain to count on. He also says some lawmakers' records still deserve a closer look.
His own money, four months
One fund, NANC, follows trades disclosed by Democrats in Congress and their spouses. The other, GOP, follows Republicans. Through Oct. 16, his NANC shares were up 3.87%. His GOP shares were down 1.07%. From June 12 through Oct. 16 a plain S&P 500 fund, the SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY), gained 2.90%. So one copycat fund finished about a point ahead of the index. The other finished about four points behind.
Read those numbers with care, as Fryer does. They count price changes only, after fund costs and without dividends. Four months is a short stretch. In some windows, he writes, both funds have beaten the market. This is a test of an idea. It isn't a scoreboard for either party.
The idea sticks anyway, and Fryer explains why. We only hear about the winners. He notes that if you test 100 investors, about five will look special by luck alone. And a 20% gain sounds great until you learn the market rose 30%.
Our read
This is a Behavioral story, and an Investments and Risk (IN04) one. The people we most suspect of having an edge mostly matched the market. That says a lot about tips from everyone else. Copying someone's trades rarely beats a plain index fund once you count costs and risk. Neither copycat fund is in any of our model books, and SPY is only a yardstick here. What Congress should do about its own trading is Congress's call.
Here's the check for your own account. Open your brokerage app and find anything you bought because someone else did. It might have been a lawmaker, a billionaire or a brother-in-law. Compare it with a plain S&P 500 index fund since the day you bought it. That's Fryer's 20% and 30% test, run on your own money. If the copies have lagged, bring the list to a review. A dull fund that owns the whole market is hard to beat.
