A few weeks ago, online stock chat rooms had a motto. It was “NVDA and chill.” Buy Nvidia, hold it, relax. That mood is gone, Jason Zweig writes in the Wall Street Journal's Weekend edition. Some investors now want out of AI stocks and into something safer. One place they may look is a fund with the word value in its name.
Value stocks are the ones that look cheap. The old test is a low price next to book value, which is what a company owns minus what it owes. Here's the catch. Chip makers have spent huge sums on factories and equipment. That lifts their book value. So they can land in a value index even when the stock is pricey by other measures.
The numbers show it. In the first 10 months of this year, the technology part of the Russell 1000 Value Index gained 88.5%. That index is a popular list of big value stocks. The tech gain helped the whole index return 24.5%. The Russell 1000 Growth index fell 0.2% over the same months. Zweig says it's the widest lead for value in any like period since the indexes began in 1987. Two stocks that counted as value did much of the work. Micron Technology (MU) gained 305% and Sandisk (SNDK) gained 858% in the first six months of the year. Both moved to the growth index when the indexes were reset in June, he adds. Many value funds are also still heavy in Amazon.com (AMZN), Apple (AAPL) and Microsoft (MSFT), he writes.
Don't try to time it
Value's edge comes and goes. From 1927 through 2025, big value stocks returned 12.3% a year, against 10.2% for big growth stocks, by the research Zweig cites. But value trailed growth over the four decades from the end of 1984 through 2024. So nobody can say how long this rebound lasts. A fund executive told him the edge can't be predicted in the short run. So timing it is pointless, Zweig writes. Zweig's last word is for people who own a broad index fund and can stay put. For them, he writes, trying to protect against a short AI drop is “probably more trouble than it's worth.”
Our read
This is an Investments/Risk (IN04) story. A label isn't a list of holdings. In our model books, the Vanguard Value ETF (VTV) is held at weight in 4 books. The Schwab dividend ETF (SCHD) is in 13 and the Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF (VYM) is in 11. Nothing was added.
Here's the check for this week. Pull up any fund in your retirement plan or IRA that calls itself a value or dividend fund. Open its top-10 holdings. Count how many are tech or chip companies. Then see how many also sit in your growth fund. If the same names show up in both, that fund isn't the hedge, or protection, you thought it was. That's no reason to sell. It's a reason to know what you own. Bring the two lists to a review and we'll sort them with you. Read the label on the jar, then open the lid.
